Woodworking
is probably one of the most enjoyable hobbies or pastimes. However,
unless you use only hand tools, it is also one of the messiest.
Power tools are notorious for creating large amounts of chips,
shavings and dust. If your workshop is in the basement or the
garage, then you already know how this material gets spread all
through the rest of the house. Even it isn't spread, it still
is not particularly healthy or safe to be working in a shop covered
in dust and wood chips.
This article
describes a simple, fairly inexpensive, yet effective way to
collect a good deal of the dust that is generated in a home workshop.
The main premise here is that you already have a shop vacuum,
with a minimum airflow rating of 100cfm. Forget, for a moment,
what horsepower rating your vacuum is. All that is important
is how much air it will move. If you have a small shop vacuum
with less that 100cfm, then this article is not for you.
You will not
find any detailed calculations here about how to size your collection
system or maximize its efficiency. What is presented is a description
of my system, how I built it and how you can do the same, all
for less than $150.00 and a few hours of your time.
Air flow through
the vacuum needs to be as close to the optimum rating of the
vacuum as possible. The Achilles heel of most vacuums is their
filter; it simply is too small to work efficiently in a dust
collection system. Fortunately, after-market replacement filters
are available which greatly increase the filter area, improve
air flow, and are easier to keep clean. In addition, these filters
trap particles of dust as small as 0.3 microns and prevent them
from getting blown out of the vacuum exhaust. The best one I
have found is the CleanStream filter by Gore.
The second
bane of shop vacuums is noise. These things fairly scream. Various
ideas have been tried to make them quieter, including constructing
elaborate mufflers. My solution is to enclose the vacuum in a
cabinet under the workbench. Having it fully enclosed makes it
much quieter. However, you must allow for the exhaust air to
get out of the cabinet. The solution is to drill some holes in
the bottom of the cabinet. With this arrangement, it is still
noisy, but it is tolerable and is no louder than the other tools.
Planning your
system is fairly straightforward. Since you are starting with
a not-too-powerful vacuum, you should try to position it as close
as possible to the main dust producing tools. This will normally
be your table saw, router table and jointer and if you have one,
your sanding centre. Please note, I did not include the planer
in this list. The planer simply produces too much heavy material
for this type of system to handle properly. You can try it, but
don't say I didn't warn you! Similarly, I doubt this type of
system would be very effective for lathe dust and chip collection.
So, try to position the vacuum between the main dust producing
tools, thereby minimizing the length of run to any one tool.
That being said, as long as you keep the overall length of the
system to less than 30 feet, you can put the vacuum almost anywhere
that is convenient. Make a sketch of your shop and the location
of your power tools. If, like me, you need to move machines around
the shop because of space limitations, sketch in the most likely
locations of the tools so you have a good idea where the various
inlets need to go. Unless you like connecting and disconnecting
hoses, plan for one connection for each machine. Once you have
your sketch, you can estimate the amount of pipe and other fitting
you need.
Piping for
the system is fairly straightforward. My local lumber store carries
2" thin wall plastic tubing for built-in vacuum systems.
This material generally costs about $0.60/foot and comes in convenient
10' lengths. They also carry all the necessary connectors, elbows,
tees and other fittings that are required. For my shop, which
measures 14' x 20', I ran piping around three of the four walls
(see Figure 1 below). I put in a total of six inlets to service
the table saw, bandsaw, jointer, router table, bench band saw
/
drill
press and one for floor cleanup.

[ Click picture for larger view. ]
The plastic
pipe is connected to each machine with flexible tubing. There
are a number of sources for this flex-pipe, but I found that
Lee Valley had the best quality at the lowest price. An 80' hose
with a swivel joint at one end costs $12.75. You need one per
machine.
The piping
is fastened to the shop wall about 4' off the floor. You can
make it higher or lower that this, but I find this is a convenient
height to reach the blast gates.
So, what are
blast gates? Well, they are "valves" that you open
when you are going to use a machine and close when you finish.
They allow
all the suction of the vacuum to be concentrated at the machine
in use, greatly improving dust collection efficiency. You can
buy blast gates in either plastic or metal, but, in the best
Scottish tradition, I chose to make my own. Figure
2 shows details
of how these were constructed from scrap material in the shop.
The key to making them is to keep all the joints as airtight
as possible. I used a hole saw to cut the opening for the pipe
and hose. I cut the opening slightly undersize and then gradually
enlarged the hole using a straight cutting router bit in the
router table until the pipe and hose were a tight friction fit
in the hole. To keep everything in place, I siliconed the pipe
and hose to the blast gate. Be careful not to get the silicone
on the gate itself...it needs to open and close freely. Once
you have gathered all the bits and pieces you can begin putting
it all together. I started at the vacuum end. With the vacuum
mounted under the bench, I needed a way to connect to the plastic
system piping. I did this by cutting a hole in the bench top
the same size as the pipe and the vacuum hose. If the two are
different diameters, which they likely are, fasten a second board
on the underside of the bench and drill a hole in it equal to
the diameter of the vacuum hose. The parts friction fit in their
respective holes. Do not put any silicone on the vacuum hose;
you want to be able to "unplug" it to take the vacuum
out for cleaning and so you can use the vacuum to clean up the
shop.
While under the cabinet doing this hookup, install a duplex receptacle
to provide power for the vacuum. As a convenience to me, I made
this a switched receptacle. The switch is on the end of a long
extension cord which normally hangs from a hook on the side of
the table saw. The built-in switch on the vacuum stays turned
on all the time. I take the receptacle switch with me to whichever
machine I'm working on and turn the vacuum on and off as I use
each machine. Alternatively, there are remote switches you can
buy to do the same thing, but they're a bit pricey and, after
all, we're trying to do this for as little as possible, right?

[ Click picture for a larger view. ]
Now it's just
a matter of measuring the length of pipe needed to go to each
inlet, fastening the pieces together and attaching them to the
wall. I did not glue the pipes together, in case I ever had a
clog and needed to take the pipes apart to get at it. I covered
each joint with duct tape to improve the seal. By the way, in
two years, I have never had a clogged pipe.
When the pipes
are in place, glue the blast gates in place and attach the flex-pipe
to the blast gates and to each machine. You may have to get some
adapters to connect the hose to your machines. For example, the
jointer has a large chute to discharge the chips. A square plastic
flange with a 4" opening, and a 4" to 2" adapter, solved that
hook up problem. I found that Busy Bee had the best selection
of pieces and were almost always cheaper than other vendors.
So, now you
have everything hooked up and you're ready to go, right? Not
quite. To make the system as efficient as possible you need to
do a few more things. For example, if you have a contractor's
type saw, you already know that the whole back of the saw is
open. You need to close this off. There are various ways to do
this, but the one I like best is to build a box around the motor
and fasten the box to the sides of the saw. Put a top on the
box and this will serve as a longer out feed table. Use pegboard
for the bottom of the box so air can get in and help keep the
motor cool. There are lots of other holes in the saw as well.
Between the top and side there are many openings; duct tape will
take care of these. The front and sides of the saw have slots
for the arbour tilt. You can cut pieces of hardboard to fit over
these. Hold the hardboard in place with fridge magnets so you
can take the covers off to tilt the arbour. You can get a plate
to attach to the bottom of the saw cabinet with an adapter to
connect to the flex hose. In my case, the saw is mounted on a
home made cabinet. An opening in the cabinet top allows dust
and debris to fall into a drawer below the saw. At the back of
the
drawer is the connection to the flex hose. The fine dust and
small chips go out the hose. The cutoff chucks stay in the drawer
which can be pulled out for emptying.
You should
do a similar treatment to the jointer. Duct tape the openings
where the base meets the cabinet. Also, duct tape any gaps in
the dust chute inside the cabinet.
Most router
tables have some form of dust collection built into the fence.
Mine has that, and in addition, the lower part of the table is
enclosed also. The dust collection hose attaches to the back
of the table and sucks dust down through the insert hole and
back through the fence. Routing is almost dust free.
There's not
much you can do to improve the dust collection on the bandsaw.
As for the sanding centre, the best I can say is most of the
dust coming off the end of the belt goes in the hose.
With other
tools, there are a variety of ways to catch the dust and chips
which get produced. With a drill press or scroll saw, you can
run a smaller flex-hose up to these machines. Duct tape makes
a handy fastening system. Alternatively, you can make brackets
and clamps to hold the hose where it will do the most good.
You will have
noticed that what I have described is a "single stage" collection
system. By that I mean that the material collected goes directly
to the vacuum. A two-stage system incorporates a cyclone or other
device between the machines and the vacuum, the purpose of which
is to collect the large pieces before they reach the vacuum.
The simplest of these is a special lid, with an inlet and outlet,
that fits over a standard garbage can. The manufacturers claim
these are very efficient. I've never tried one, primarily because
I do not have the room. I think it reasonable to assume that
on a larger, more powerful system, there is likely great benefit
to a two-stage system, particularly one employing a cyclone.
On a small system, I think the benefits are marginal. However,
if you find that your system usage requires you to be constantly
emptying the vacuum, then you certainly want to think about putting
in one of these, or upgrading to a bigger, more powerful, system.
One thing I
haven't talked about is grounding the system. Conventional wisdom
seems to be that plastic pipe should be grounded to prevent static
build up and possible dust explosions. Personally, I think the
dangers are greatly exaggerated in the home-shop environment.
However, if you feel more comfortable, install a copper ground
wire inside the plastic pipe and connect it to a suitable ground.
One other aspect
of dust control in the workshop is that of airborne dust which
the dust collection system does not capture. For this you need
an air filtration system. There are lots of different ones on
the market, or you can make your own. I have a commercially made
filter system, but, since I built the dust collection system,
I rarely need to turn on the air filter unless I'm using the
belt or random orbit sander or I'm cutting or routing a messy
material like MDF.
System
Cost:
Quantity |
Item |
Cost |
1 |
CleanStream
Filter |
$41.95 |
3 |
2"
x 10' plastic duct |
$15.09 |
5 |
90
degree 3 way tees |
$
8.05 |
4 |
90
degree sweep elbows |
$
3.92 |
12 |
Pipe
straps |
$
3.84 |
1 |
3
way elbow |
$
2.24 |
2 |
Switch
boxes |
$
5.18 |
1 |
Toggle
switch |
$
1.59 |
2 |
Switch
plates |
$
0.19 |
5 |
2-1/2"
x 80" Flex hose |
$63.75 |
. |
Total |
$145.80 |
| Note: Prices may vary
depending on your area. |
|