To
begin, it is useful to know how the different types of
raw, blade materials are manufactured. This will give you a
better
understanding of the types of blades available. For example,
did you know that more than one brand of blade is made
from the same steel? This is because there are only about six
major
steel manufacturers in the world producing the strip steel
used to make bandsaw blades. The process of making a blade
begins with steel being drawn and flattened into ribbon
stock. It looks exactly like it sounds: long ribbons of steel.
Raw,
ribbon stock is fed, ganged (many strips side by side)
into a milling machine. The teeth are cut, or milled, into
the ribbon
steel. This creates a flat blade with teeth. The flat blade
is then
put through a state-of-the-art-computer, ‘run setting’ machine
which bends, or sets, each tooth slightly. The set to the teeth of
the blade is what creates the kerf, or gap, in the cut, and makes
movement of the work piece possible. The final stage in the production
of bandsaw, coil stock is the hardening process. Most manufacturers
use induction hardening,
however, some still use a flame process. Regardless of the type of
hardening process, heat is applied to the teeth, and then oil quenched,
which ‘case’ or surface hardens the teeth of the blade. In
the case of hard back material, this process of hardening is
applied to the teeth and also to the back of the material.
With this basic
understanding of how bandsaw material is manufactured, let’s
take a look at the different blades and their uses.
Anyone
who has purchased a new bandsaw machine will be familiar with
the spring
steel blade. This is usually the type of blade which comes with
the machine. Just as its name implies, this blade is made of
a thin spring
like material. It is used on three wheel bandsaw machines. Its
soft, highly elastic composition provides the flexibility that
is important
for extended-blade life. Generally, these blades have a low tooth
rockwell (universal standard for measuring hardness) of 46RC.
The most commonly available and economical blade is the carbon
hard edge
flex back, which is made of pinpoint carbon steel and has a flexible
back. It is available in a variety of widths and teeth per inch.
They usually possess a tooth hardness of 60-62RC, far harder
than the spring steel blade. Similar to the carbon flex back
is the carbon
hard edge, hard back. This is manufactured in the same manner
as the flex back, but with the added benefit of having the
back case
hardened to 50RC. It will perform better in situations which
require a higher feed pressure, especially on power feed machines.
The
furniture band blade is similar to the hard back. It is
a carbon blade and is used
primarily by the furniture frame industry.
It is made of a thicker gauge carbon material, with a heavy set
to the teeth. This makes the furniture band blade perfect for fast
cutting, while providing greater beam strength. This blade has
also been readily adopted by wood turners and carvers for roughing
out blanks. New for the hobbyist market, is the silicon bandsaw
blade. It is still a carbon steel band, however, it contains a
higher percentage of silicon, or tungsten which gives the blade
a higher tooth rockwell of 68RC. The blade stays sharper for a
longer period of time and can withstand higher temperatures without
fatiguing. In addition, the hard back gives you the ability to
maintain a vertical straightness with less tension. It is a highly
efficient blade, especially when re-sawing with a bandsaw machine
under 1 horsepower. This type of blade has a longer life and is,
from this standpoint, highly economical. Bi-metal blades are a
steel blade with a M2 or M42 high speed steel tip. It has a very
high rockwell tooth. While manufactured in a similar fashion as
the carbon and silicon bands, some significant differences exist
in the composition of the bi-metal blade. It is made from two types
of steel: a high speed ribbon is fused to a spring steel body,
hence the name, Bi-metal. The teeth are milled and set in the same
manner as other blades, however, the hardening is done in an atmospheric
furnace, at significantly higher temperatures, for longer periods
of time. It is often used for cutting extremely hard or abrasive
products, such as metal, while maintaining its sharpness. Unfortunately,
it can cost five times more than a good carbon bandsaw blade. A
Bi-metal blade will stay sharper for a longer period of time, however,
it does require a higher tension for optimum performance and to
maintain vertical straightness. The carbide tipped blade consists
of carbide tips which have been welded to the ribbon steel and
then ground. This blade, however, can cost from fifteen to twenty
times that of a carbon band.
Now
we have reviewed the different types of blades available on
the market,
the true
challenge is figuring out which blade is
best for you and your project. The average woodworker need not
concern themselves with the Bi-metal or carbide tipped blades.
They are fairly specialized in their applications and can be costly.
Your best options are the carbon flex or hard back and the silicon
bandsaw blade. It is most likely that your woodworking falls into
the general cutting category, that is: not too tight, and not too
thick. In this case, a good general purpose blade would be a 1/4"
or 3/8" by 6 tooth per inch hook blade. Keep in mind that
the thicker the wood, the coarser the tooth pitch (number of teeth
per inch).
If a straight cut is your focus, then a wider blade would be a
better option. However, a wider blade will require more power to
run, so be sure to balance the horse power of your machine with
the blade size. Often, a blade such as the silicon band is a better
choice because they are not any thicker or wider than a normal
blade. They don’t require as much power to run and because
of the hard tooth and hard back, they can stay very straight vertically
and linearly. As an added bonus, they are also resistant to fatigue.
As a rule, the tighter the radius, the smaller the
width of the blade, and the greater the pitch of the tooth. Unfortunately,
burning occurs when the normal blade speed of 3000 F.P.M. does
not allow for the higher pitched blade's smaller teeth to clear
the saw dust. As a result, it has a chance to bind and generate
heat, causing burning to the project. This will limit the thickness
of the material you can cut. The heat friction also further fatigues
the blade. If, however, you can slow the blade speed on your machine
you should be able to get away with cutting a little thicker material,
while reducing burning. Once the speed has been reduced, there
is ample time for the sawdust to clear. For a well rounded selection
of blades for your shop, I would suggest the following three widths
to start: 3/16 X 10TPI, 1/4 X 6TPI and 1/2 X 3TPI. After that you
might want to consider the 3/8 x 4 or 6TPI.
This
selection will cover most of the hobbyist’s woodworking
needs for a reasonable cost. Then, if you find yourself using
one width
more than another,
upgrade to a silicon band.